Hes essentially trapped in being the caretaker for his mom. July 10, 2021 Investigation Discovery's 'The Lake Erie Murders: Blood in the Water' chronicles the brutal killing of 10-year-old Holly Jones in Ontario, Canada. The album finishes with the very first line from the first song: So I was takin a walk the other day Its a line that begins a situation where Kendrick gets shot and killed. I stumbled upon this essay and now cant wait to watch again. Thats a great question! Regarding the above comments, I recall the detectives discussing the results of forensics on the body in the priests hole. Youre so thorough and the ending is brilliant. But, at this point, you know better than to think its coincidence, right? But the more you dig into Prisoners it eventually becomes clear as day that the entire movie is this layered exploration of various types of prisons: physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual. He equally needs the cold and frosty weather because hes shot and maybe this will keep him alive a little longer (dont know, I am not a doctor) or keep the drug from effectively knocking him out. The disappearance of Holly Jones Holly left home at 6:00 PM while it was still daylight, but as the darkness grew, her parents, Maria Jones and George Stonehouse, became concerned. Like inNocturnal Animals we have three stories being told. Alias How did he get to Hollys house? CSP-SAC is on 882 acres, sharing this property with Folsom State Prison, Folsom Women's Facility, and California Prison Industry Authority. I guess the priest didnt report because it was a confession and he felt unable to tell authorities about it? What a brilliant dissection of it all. Details. Other questions. And Im pretty sure Holly Joness original kid was named Alex? Both Taylor and Alex are old enough that they could physically move beyond what happened to them. A symbol that we can hear each other if we listen from inside. Im only 13 minutes in right now, but it is interesting! The article mentions that his co-worker Mr Dover didnt make any comments. I noticed how Holly cares for her dog and I wonder if Alex abusing it is his way of getting back at her (His abuser). The little girls are not the same (one clings to her mother for dear life and the other is stoic)? [3] Is arrested as the prime suspect. Holly and her husband, who used to be fundamentalist believers, might have practised snake-handling as part of their faith and would have kept snakes for that purpose. Though Keller was having a most difficult time thinking and behaving Christian or Christ-like, their never was a scene where he cursed God or threw away his cross. Keller doesnt get the answer he seeks from all the torture HE did, but by Joys miraculous escape and him making the connection that she saw him at some point. Cant wait to show this movie (and analysis) to my wife! Its no longer Alex being the byproduct of Holly and her husband, or being cruel just to be cruel. Thanks, Warren! Hes only reacting to the abduction because it reminds him of his own and he starts to copycat, reliving the nightmare of what he experienced with Holly and her husband. But on the way back they saw the van and decided to play on it since their older siblings werent there to tell them no. Keller Dover wiederum fhrt zu Holly Jones, da er den Verdacht hat, dass Joy dort seine Stimme gehrt haben knnte. Also, I wanted to add that it is mentioned that Alex had an accident with the snakes. Its too easy to say Oh, well, they were completely messed up because of their own abductions when they were kids! And as you said yourself the whole plot development depends a bit too much on the fact that neither Alex nor Taylor are willing to talk about their experiences. Chris, this is an excellent analysis that I thoroughly enjoyed reading. On Friday, Briere was charged with abducting, murdering and dismembering 10-year-old Holly Jones (shown), some of whose body parts were found May 13 in two pieces of luggage in water in two . There are a ton of changes that could be made to make this subplot more efficient and straightforward. Mini Major Victory At Olympia '08 For Ellen Whitaker & Holly Jones. Hey! The profound trauma capable of changing the intrinsic nature of a person, their beliefs, their language. Cornton Vale I believe. Anyway thanks for the insight. Within hours of her disappearance, police launch a massive search and issue an "Amber Alert," a. I love it that youre so active in the comments and engaging with readers, it encourages me (and hopefully other readers) to revisit movies with new perspectives in mind and discuss further. She forces him to drink a drugged liquid, causing him to feel faint. The justification given by Keller Snr. Please also note the professors I have been working with at the end of this video. Finally returning to the movie and looked into this. While Norse mythology roots in paganism and associates with the natural world. Prisoners is a 2013 American thriller film directed by Denis Villeneuve from a screenplay written by Aaron Guzikowski. Eloquently posited Jeff, this certainly fits into the message and subsequent explanation for me. MARSHALL COUNTY, Ala. (TCD) -- A woman from Albertville was sentenced to 99 years in prison for charges of sodomy, sexual torture, and bestiality. Why isnt the aunts house and grounds searched with dogs? Your movie analysis is very very great. The highly anticipated conclusion to the Stolen Heir duology by #1 New York Times bestselling author Holly Black. Gyllenhaal was just OK, not especially convincing. Theres a version where he moves the car and sees Hugh down there, and so on. Because Holly cant steal children easily on her own, fewer children go missing. The main villain is in a war against the Christian God, while the hero is named after a god of Norse mythology. Why? in public-policy analysis, UNC-Chapel Hill; master's of divinity . Hes a red herring that creates doubt about Alex. This is the best analysis I have read. Holly Road 704-461-6200 704-461-6236 . There are SO many other examples of this in the film! Bob Taylor didnt have the opportunity. Despite her knowing all this, remembering all of this, what does she express? All he would have been able to see is Holly crouching over the girl. Holly eventually admits to Keller she cant really abduct kids without her husband so hasnt been as active. Without your amazing, insight ful comments I would never have got any of it at all. In the largest mass commutation in US history, at least . Lets get some answers. Its a really great movie. Once a loving and religious woman, both Holly and her husband's minds soon took a twisted turn when their son died of cancer. It had happened in broad daylight, in the Junction Triangle neighborhood in west Toronto, and detectives would find out later there were witnesses. The best answer I can think of is its been long enough and theyre desperate enough for any lead that they dont question it. The facility was expanded in 1996 and now includes 18 . 303 East Church Street Post Office Box 69 919-894-3616 919-894-2091 . It made me wonder if he also was carrying around some past trauma. As a forensic psychologist I also question the alleged motives of some of Alexs and Taylors actions. While SCDC strives to ensure accuracy of this information, it makes no guarantees as to the reliability of the data. I thought that Alex and Bob had kidnapped the girls and Bob had left Alex to take the fall. Or say something. This writeup helped explain a few things I was uncertain of but I still found too many parts of the movie unbelievable and just plain frustrating. At one point her husband confessed his crimes to a local priest, out of a narcissistic boldness of feeling unable to get caught. Franklin says and believes that he would do anything for his daughter, but ( like Peter in the Bible who acted cowardly when he thought he would act bravely at Christs crucifixion ) Franklin (who thinks he can play the trumpet, but cant) is not a killer. . Thats why Keller being a carpenter, just like Jesus was, cant be a coincidence, I think. A small foreshadowing detail I noticed is when Alex signs his name to be released from the police, its revealed that his middle name is Winterman which is a reference to a book by the same name by Alex Walters about a serial killer that targets children. And is still stuck in it, so to speak. None of us really wanted to do that version, but we wanted to make sure we had it in case once the film was put together it seemed like it really needed it. So many twists and turns. Its Hollys husband, and hes wearing the same maze necklace as the mysterious body from the basement. Beyond that, the story plays out in such a way that it intentionally leaves viewers to put together key details. Its a solid theory. Alex succumbs to Kellers torture and mentions a maze, so Keller goes to Hollys house to see if she will reveal something about a maze. Another thing is the significance of showing the prepper mindset and taking everything in his own hand and his general lack of trust in higher authorities including police and perhaps even more broadly God, and how that changed when he was in the most helpless situation in what he prepared nothing for, and yet found that red whistle which will save his life. Among 747 males the risk of being a perpetrator was positively correlated with reported sexual abuse victim experiences. And others will have a more cynical outlook that hes become who hes become and is kind of terrifying. Some people will choose the hopeful outlook that being away from Holly means he has a chance at a decent future. Additionally, this would explain the necklace. To the point where they said the center of the entire universe was a gigantic tree named Yggdrasil. Ralph tries to protest and is silenced by an outburst from Keller. Origin I almost enjoyed this analysis more than the movie. I also have a question. This is due to the detective leading the case, Detective Loki, finding what he believes to be evidence in Bob's house, finding blood-stained cloths, making it appear that he'd murdered the girls. He had no criminal record, not even a parking ticket to his name. Unbeknownst to him, Joy and Anna are in another room and Joy sees him/hears him. How could the FBI agent wrote a book about the murderer and even have a maze picture in it if: a. no children was ever found (alive or not); b. the murderer was never found. Other interesting fact about the snakes: they have a connection with Loki too. Also could represent David and Goliath and figuring out the maze was a Goliath task. Demonstrated history of leadership in Human Resources Strategy, Employee Relations . I have kids and if they were ever kidnapped I would pick them being killed than for them to do what Alex did. This is reinforced later by Joys struggles to explain what had happened to her, only able to look at Keller and say, You were there. It put tape on my mouth. But in the moments before she speaks, we see Joys memory of escaping, the flashes of being in the house, on the ground, someone leaving the room, the book of mazes they had to complete, running away. Which would therefore create a maze of the mind and memories. But then you look at the structure of Prisoners, how it tells its story, how it reveals information, theres an understanding that the maze stuff wasnt just to spice up the thrills (as some people have complained). What follows are the vital details of Prisonersstudied, analyzed, deconstructed, dissected, unraveled, and presented for your review. I could see that. We expect psychos to have weird obsessions like mazes. Three years later, as he was serving a 23-year prison sentence at the United States Disciplinary Barracks at Fort Leavenworth, Kan., Jones failed to report for a prison check after working in a . She tells him that her and her husband have been waging a war on God and shows Keller where she hid Anna. My question is when Loki found Keller tortureing Alex, why wasnt he taken to the police station? He was the guy with boyish good. By leaving that choice in our hands, the film becomes a moment of reflection, of confrontation. If Keller could figure it out, it was just a matter of time before Loki did too. In the hospital, Joy says to Keller, You were there, which Keller realizes means Hollys house and that Holly wasnt an innocent old lady. While Lokis faith in following signs guides him right to the imprisoned Keller. I actually know the answer to this! I dont buy it. I think the movie is definitely one of the best of its decade. Duct tape: I think were supposed to accept it lol. And even if all four parents were confused when they looked at the items which is highly unlikely the investigators should have noticed that according to the parents the items in Taylors possession were not worn by the girls on the day of their abduction. Rather than the cast elevating in their own way. Loki goes to the Jones's house to tell her that her nephew has been found. moment. That really ties it all together, doesnt it? Accepting not just the bad but the good as well. It seemed to me that Holly heard Lokis car pulling up in her drive way, why would she decide to try to kill Anna with a syringe at that moment? I was so impatient with all the people not talking, but it makes sense now, the priest, bound by his guilt and confession rules, Alex, most likely having been drugged from an early age on which alters your brain and personality, and God knows what else these people did to him and Bob. Its like the negotiating tactic of not saying anything. Alex says In the maze, and Bob simply draws it. The dude has severe burns and 20+ counts of kidnapping (molestation???) Alex Jones also refers to a maze. Holly Jones Community Partnership & Outreach Coordinator at North Carolina Department of Justice Asheville, North Carolina, United States 3K followers 500+ connections Join to connect North. Barely existing. The kidnapping stunted both young men. They promptly reported her missing, and an "Amber alert" was issued the next morning. Look Up An Inmate Benson NC Police Jail. When you realize one of the names has a deeper meaning, it leads to the question: Do the rest of the names have meaning? This brings us back to Grace and Loki and Dover and Birch, etc. The standard Hollywood police chief who constantly undermines the investigation is so completely overused. Why didnt Alex confess to the police or Keller? It seems accusatory at first mostly because its confusing. They were scared enough to shut down and didnt move much/touch much until Alex dropped them off. So, maybe after recalling what Annas mother said, he might be able to link that to the sound of the whistle at Hollys house and try to find Keller. Yeah, it seems thats the case. This movie is called Prisoners, but the title isn't meant to simply reference Bob Taylor as a prisoner of Detective Loki, or Alex Jones as the hostage of Keller Dover, or even Anna and Joy as. After the police let Alex go, Keller kidnaps Alex. And then refuses to reveal anything to Keller, despite the constant torture, despite Kellers utter desperation and desolation. Holly and her husband could have found comfort in one anotherinstead their crusade ends up resulting in both of their deaths. Yo Zach! I wonder if perhaps he was strangled by a snake for a time, causing a lack of oxygen in his brain, which could also add to the severe mental damage he displays. Kind of similar to the movie Zodiac. Or the DA who brought the charges would lose their next election lol. The soul. That becomes enough for them to not question it. Constantly updated. I imagine this is part of the routine for her prisoners that keeps them in a lethargic state in their imprisonment. This is the man who saved Anna, and Anna doesnt say a word to him, despite being prompted by her mom. I didnt think Maria Bello was good either. We (and Keller) struggle to understand whats going through Alexs mind. For some (many?) The whole piece around the priest and Hollys husband seems a little loose to me. Wow, that was so helpful. Or, if it was still his parents, quite surprised! Keller soon realizes that Holly was the real kidnapper. Did Hollys husband have more dirt on the priest that could have gotten him in more trouble? I mean, maybe I did in terms of Keller and Jesus lol. confused just by this bit. Replace the fridge with the old car. Alex drives his RV to the house he had been abducted from in 1987, the home of his actual parents. Lokis fellow officer brought it up that the Invisible Man used an LSD/ketamine cocktail on the victims, as described by that book. Their sonstill a childdies, causing them tremendous grief. Imitates kidnapping children. Whats it mean that Keller prays to God to save him from the hole and its Loki whos there? Who was the guy in the priests basement? The exact opposite of what you would expect him to do based on what you know about his religion. Commenting on the arrest, Police Chief Julian Fantino made an angry plea to government to set up a DNA bank for all software developers. Can you explain the girls flashback when she sees Keller? I prefer to believe Keller was found by Loki, his boss said he never lost a case. 127 South Second Street 919-989-5040 . The Monkey and Rooster zodiac signs, which Jake discusses with the waitress foreshadow the character traits of Jake (Loki) and Hugh (Keller). Also, I thought Holly was injecting Anna with venom and that Loki was rushing the girl to hospital to get her the anti-venom in time. Holly Deane-Johns, 51, was subjected to the awful living conditions while serving time at Lardyao Women's Correctional Institution. star wars hologram projector; how to interpret histogram with . His aunt also says that he just wanted to play and thats why he took the girls. Reporter: Heather Hiscox, from The National, December 19 and Canada Now, December 19-23, 2003. Its always really nice to have that experience where you grow into appreciating a movie. Regarding Alex. I would love to hear your take on the current covid crisis and response. Hi Chris Though she is not suspected by the police, Alex is, as the girls were seen playing around his RV before the capture. People are complicated. He needs someone like Loki to be there at the right place and time! What a coincidence that the character with that name ends the movie in a hole in the ground?! But his instinct, thoroughness, and curiosity get the better of him. What ending do we choose? He was subsequently killed by the priest, who threw the body into the church's basement. I felt he was trapped moreso in the house by the news vans crowding round. Theres Amy Adamss character going about her life in the present day. Armed with a hidden gun, Keller heads to see Holly, but she soon learns he knows she kidnapped the girls and prepares her own revolver, which she aims at him upon arrival without hesitation once he voices he knows the truth. But sometime during Kellers torture of Alex, the dynamic changes. Holly and her husband based their abductions off of the book. Why does that trigger a flashback where she thinks he was there? Ive never read such a detailed and thorough review of a movie (well aside from LOTR-but that has a whole cult following). The Central Mississippi Correctional Facility (CMCF) was established in 1986 and built on 171 acres in Pearl in Rankin County. The pair began kidnapping children to turn the parents into 'demons' as they called it, forcing them to lose their mind and faith like they did. 69K views 2 years ago In Pennsylvania, Keller Dover, his wife Grace, son Ralph, and daughter Anna celebrate Thanksgiving with their friends Franklin and Nancy Birch, and their daughters Eliza and. 2.) You know hes going to be taken out of the hole. Seems like something he would do in private. Thats the only way he can communicate to Loki where the girls might be, what happened to him, etc. Buddy Holly was a singer songwriter from Lubbock Texas who died after a short 18 month career. One of these underground people tells a shocked family, Were Americans. After that information, the title, Us, can be read as US, or U.S., or United States. A normal person probably doesnt run off like that. This is purposefully meta, as midway through the film the motif of the maze is introduced. My question is, why didnt he just tell the detective everything right then! I dont recall that moment, if you dont mind refreshing my memory! holly jones prisoners. But so many people missed this concept that Kendrick actually released a special edition of the album that was reverse chronological order. They accept what their instincts tell them and both end up playing the hero. (601) 932-2880. I get thinking Alex not talking is weird/problematic. How? I noticed this strange bit of dialogue from Loki: You know IF YOU KNOW something One question that bugs me if Alex took the 2 girls in the RV, how comes the forensic team didnt find any trace of them? Prisoners Search Criteria: Last Name: First Name: Also known as: infinity. Thanks Chris for your work here! Who knows! I thought that Alex and Bob were weirder than they needed to be, and in their bizarreness, not real, and therefore, not anyone that I could mourn for, though what theyd been through was terrible. How do we make sense of the bad that happens in the world? He always closes a case and he said he would find Keller, 2. -Prisons (physical, emotional, mental, spiritual)-Mazes-Religion. Why couldnt Loki identify the dead body as that of Hollys husband? The film stars Hugh Jackman, Jake Gyllenhaal, Viola Davis, Terrence Howard, Maria Bello, Melissa Leo, and Paul Dano. They said specifically that the DNA and dental records came back with no match. A character whose first scene is talking about Zodiac signs. Jones She reveals that she heard Keller while she was held captive. The pause on Netflix is infuriating. Joy and Anna leave the Birchs to find Annas missing whistle. Before we talk about mazes, lets talk about in-roads. She heads to where she is hiding Anna and plans to kill her and taunt Keller by throwing her dead body into the hole with him. We know this for a few reasons. Why did Hollys husband brag/confess to him? We see from your examples (Alex telling Keller his girls cried after being interrogated, and his torture of the dog) that the abuse he has suffered has caused him to become capable of abuse himself. High intelligenceGunmanship I loved the movie and really appreciate you breaking it down like that. Perhaps it was intended to reflect his personality, peaceable in normal situations, but with a killer instinct ready to take over when pushed by circumstances. They dont expect someone to break into their house and take clothing. SCDC offers the Internet "inmate search" feature and the toll free inmate information line, 1-866-727-2846, as a public service to interested citizens. Then took them back to Holly. Under certain agreements and special circumstances, we . The list of things that Buddy did before anyone else is long. Excellent insight, Jasmine! Its a huge part of the religionlikea cornerstone of Christian theology. Theres a second Alex in Prisoners. I searched for more movies with the actor Jack G after watching Nortunal Animals. I thought this was the whole reason behind Keller being obsessed with preparing for the worst, that his dad had been facing something he was unable to cope with and killed himself as his only way out of that situation. Mark just pointed that out in another comment! The girls never mention a second man either. Joy and Anna see the RV while on a walk with their siblings, Ralph and Eliza. He was the 28-year-old from Woodstock charged with Tori Stafford's abduction, rape and murder. Occupation Child abuseDruggingKidnappingMurderTorture I like it much better being ambiguous. One has the last name Dover. And how do we make sense of the miracles in our lives? Its almost as though his body forces him tobut during the chase to save Annas life, Loki was driving blind. Its likely that since the girls probably went from the van to the hole that the scent wasnt lingering in a way the dogs would notice. I imagine it would have taken some time to make the connection to Hollys husband, if it was ever possible to do so. She was portrayed by Melissa Leo, who also played Sally in Oblivion . He needs grace and so does Lokihe relies heavy on his ability to observe and pay attention to details. Great Read thanks for the detailed and thorough breakdown. Not to mention how tattoos relate to paganism and Norse culture. We know the girls were interested in the van. I am bothered by the fact that there were no traces at all of the two girls found in the camper van, although they have been abducted in that van! We only know that from Kellers dream, right? Thats an interesting point about the zodiac signs! Yeah, I like the mixture of Christian and Norse. The whole concept of a maze is that people become lost in the convolutions and complications of the structure. The body had been decomposing for a number of years. So the star on Det. So you could try and argue that it just means the girls didnt struggle. Now imagine Taylor and Alex being there for years and years. My question is who is the person that Joy sees in her flashback? Plus, excellent point that they wouldnt just jump to Oh! I must reiterate how spectacular this review was. We see many crosses. Prisoners is a 2013 American mystery thriller film directed by Denis Villeneuve from a screenplay written by Aaron Guzikowski. In the scene in which Prisoners, directed by sci-fi movie master Denis Villeneuve, reveals that Holly was responsible for the kidnapping, it is also revealed that Taylor was a former victim of the Jones' that actually escaped, and Holly forgot he existed until he appeared in the news. The book would lack meaning because it lacked any and all context. The next thing I remember is the detectives discussing giving Holly notice about Alex. Devoid of humor, just not especially real. I thought that Holly was the best performance, a bit melodramatic, but very creepy and a smooth transition from Auntie to Killer. The breath. But the CSI experts would surely have noticed if the van had been cleaned very recently, and that small detail would have been suspicious as well.
Robert Scott Wilson Liberty Mutual,
Sullivan And Cromwell Vacation Scheme,
Wnba Athletic Training Internships,
Articles H